Tayyab Murtaza logoTayyab MurtazaClinical Psychologist & Hypnotherapist
All articles

Overthinking

Why Overthinking Feels Productive — But Rarely Is

Most people who overthink are not lazy thinkers. They are trying very hard to solve something — usually something that cannot be solved by thinking about it again.

By Tayyab Murtaza, Clinical Psychologist & Hypnotherapist · 28 January 2026 · 5 min read

Problem-solving vs rumination

Problem-solving is time-limited, moves toward a decision, and ends with an action. Rumination circles the same ground, focuses on why rather than what next, and leaves you more tired than when you began.

A useful test: after twenty minutes of thinking, has anything changed? If the answer is consistently no, the thinking has become rumination.

What helps

Attention training, scheduled worry-time, and cognitive defusion techniques all reduce the grip of repetitive thought. So does addressing what the overthinking is protecting you from — often uncertainty, judgement or a decision you are avoiding.

Where sleep is affected, a wind-down routine and relaxation work are usually built into the plan.

Common questions

Can I stop overthinking on my own?
Some people can, using structured self-help. If the pattern is long-standing or affecting sleep, work or relationships, professional support is usually faster and more durable.

Continue reading on overthinking

This article is part of our overthinking resource hub, which brings together the related articles and the psychological services that address it.

Related services

  • Overthinking & Rumination — Therapy for repetitive thinking loops, mental replaying and difficulty switching off.
  • Anxiety Management — Support for persistent worry, physical tension and anticipatory fear using structured, evidence-informed methods.
  • Sleep & Relaxation Support — Non-medical therapeutic support for difficulty falling asleep, waking at night and unrefreshing rest.

Ready to talk it through?

A single assessment appointment with Tayyab Murtaza, Clinical Psychologist & Hypnotherapist, is the clearest way to understand what you are experiencing and what would help. Sessions are available in person in Lahore and securely online across Pakistan and internationally.

Ask a question on WhatsApp

About the author

Tayyab Murtaza is a Clinical Psychologist & Hypnotherapist and Founder of Fatima Hope and Psychological Centre, offering assessment, psychological therapy, group therapy and clinical hypnotherapy in Lahore and online. He holds a Master's degree in Clinical Psychology from International Islamic University, Islamabad (IIUI).

This content is for educational purposes and does not replace professional psychological assessment or treatment. If you are in crisis or at risk of harm, seek urgent local medical help.

WhatsApp